Wine Club Reviews & Ratings

Expert reviews and tips for buying a monthly wine club—for yourself or as a gift

Best Wine Clubs

Our wine club reviews help you pick the best wine of the month club for you!


Top 5 Best Wine Clubs

Top 5 Best Wine Clubs

We've hand-selected these wine clubs for you because: They exceed our expectations as compared to similar wine clubs; They offer better value or a better selection of wines than similar wine of the month clubs; Our readers prefer these to similar clubs.

See the Top 5 Best Wine Clubs

Also All Wine Club Reviews

Best Red Wine Clubs

Best Red Wine Clubs

The best red wine clubs are a mix of two things: the best wine clubs overall, and getting the most value on red wine (which can be expensive for the good stuff). We sifted through our independent wine club reviews to figure out which wine clubs are really the best red wine clubs. These red wine clubs are sure to delight.

See the Best Red Wine Clubs

Also Red Wine Club Reviews

Best White Wine Clubs

Best White Wine Clubs

Not surprisingly, there are a number of amazing values in white wine clubs. Since white wine is often cheaper than read for similar quality, we went even further with our best white wine clubs list, looking for the clubs that offer you interesting whites, not just good whites. Use our reviews to further refine your selection.

See the Best White Wine Clubs

Also White Wine Club Reviews

Best California Wine Clubs

Best California Wine Clubs

When it comes to California wine clubs, we've reviewed the most. And probably tasted the most, too. We live in California and frequently go wine tasting at the wineries. We know which producers deliver tremendous value, and then we use this information when we review all wine clubs featuring California wines.

See the Best California Wine Clubs

Also California Wine Club Reviews

Best Wine Club Gifts

Best Wine Club Gifts

A monthly wine club makes for a wonderful gift, for any type of wine lover. If your recipient drinks occasionally, or is someone you don’t know really well, you’ll find this selection of best wine club gift reviews a perfect place to shop. Great packaging, consistently good-quality wines, and of course the thoughtfulness of a wine gift that keeps on giving.

See the Best Wine Club Gifts

Also Wine Club Gift Reviews

Most Interesting Wine Clubs

Most Interesting Wine Clubs

There are many “standard” two-bottle of the month wine clubs out there—one white, one red, virtually (and often literally) guaranteed not offend anyone. But if you’re intrigued by the unusual, distinctive, or boutique wines of the world, we suggest you take a look at this list of Most Interesting wine clubs.

See the Most Interesting Wine Clubs

Wine Club Gifts

The excitement of a monthly wine delivery, elaborate newsletters with recipes for food pairings and educational articles, and boutique wines will delight any wine drinker.

Wine of the month clubs make excellent gifts for any type of wine drinker.

» Shop all of our Wine Club Gifts
» Shop our Best Wine Club Gifts

Wine Gift Baskets

Say Thank You or Congratulations or Happy Birthday! Wine basket gifts come with snacks and special bottles of wine to show how much you care. We've hand-picked the best ones for you.

Wine basket gifts are a great way to help celebrate any occasion.

» Shop all of our Wine Basket Gifts

Wine Gift Sets

If you're buying a gift for a wine lover we highly recommend exploring wine gift sets. These hand-picked sets come with 2-4 bottles, in unusual packaging, with high-end accessories, or just really great wines.

Wine gift sets are the ideal gifts for the wine enthusiasts in your life.

» Shop all of our Wine Gift Sets

Did you know?
Shipping wine is complicated!

If you live in one of the alcohol-friendly states, it probably never occurred to you that we have some arcane shipping laws in this country when it comes to alcohol. This makes purchasing a wine club as a gift, or even for yourself, just a teeny bit more challenging.

FedEx will ship wine clubs to the green states in the map, IF the wine club has a license to do so in that state. Those purple states are mostly off limits to FedEx, but other shippers might be able to send wine to them. See how this gets complicated quickly?

But never fear! WineClubReviews is here! We've organized the wine clubs we've reviewed into handy "ship to state" pages, so you can send your wine to Maryland, Pennsylvania, and even Utah (well, maybe not Utah).

» Ship wine to Georgia
» Ship wine to Maryland
» Ship wine to Massachusetts
» Ship wine to New Jersey
» Ship wine to Pennsylvania
» Ship wine to Texas

If your state isn't listed above, you can still refine your shopping experience on our site to only see wine clubs that will ship to your state by following this link:

» The Full List of States to Ship Wine

Our Latest Wine Club Reviews

Visit this wine club

Le Metro Wine Subscription Review

Published July 26, 2014
Get ready to have your socks knocked off. Le Metro Wine—an up-start wine company made up of creative collaborators based in San Diego—has come up with a wine "club" concept for the oenophile and the art-lover... really for anyone with and adventurous spirit.

Read the Le Metro Wine Subscription Review

Visit this wine club

Plonk Wine Club Review

Published July 26, 2014
Plonk is at it again! Recognizing that there just aren't that many great wine clubs for adventurous wine drinkers, and understanding that some of us, ahem, drink more than others, has launched their 12-bottle Case Club! Same great wines as their original 4-bottle club, but get 3x as many in each shipment and save a little extra dough for buying a bigger quantity.

Read the Plonk Case Club Review

Visit this wine club

Global Wine Cellars Review

Published May 19, 2014
Global Wine Cellars, a new entrant on the wine club scene, isn't new to wine clubs at all. Having provided the service as a private label to some of America's top branded wine clubs, they're branching out and offering their unique brand of wine curation directly to consumers.

Read the Global Wine Cellars Discovery Club Review

Visit this wine club

Forbes Wine Club by Lot18 Review

Published May 18, 2014
Forbes got in the game by asking personalized wine club powerhouse Tasting Room by Lot18 for a private label version of their successful quarterly wine club. We'd be remiss if we didn't include their awesomeness alongside that of Tasting Room.

Read the Forbes Wine Club Review

Visit this wine club

WSJWine Wine Club Review

Updated May 9, 2014
The WSJWine Wine Club has added a new introductory offer to their line-up, but it's just for you! Well, you and any other visitors! We've got an exclusive on a Gold Medal Reds "case" (15 wines) chock-full of premium red wines, compared to their normal assortment, that carry that special Gold Medal label.

Check out the new, exclusive offer!

Visit this wine club

Premier Series by The California Wine Club Review

Updated December 31, 2013
We've been watching The California Wine Club for over four years now, and we felt it was time for an update to this now outdated review. We've been impressed by quality at this price-point, which has remained steady while the costs of wine and their competitors' prices keep going up. This is now a highly-recommended California Wine Club that's great for yourself or as a gift.

Read the full review


We bet you already know what we do... yep you guessed it, we review wine clubs. We do this to help wine-lovers find the best wine club for themselves or as a gift, all in the name of enjoying drinking wine on any budget.

Our wine club reviews consist of several steps to ensure the wine clubs we have on the site are well-vetted. These wine club review steps include:

Check Out the Wines: We review the wines each wine club has sent in the past (as shown on their own website or, if needed, as requested via email). We verify awards and points, as well as size of production, and we evaluate Quality-to-Price Ratio (QPR). Whenever possible we receive shipments from the wine clubs to keep a trained eye on the quality, too.

Scout the Deals: We look to see what kinds of discounts and perks the wine clubs offer their members. Some wine clubs have introductory offers or provide free-shipping so we want to know about that, too.

Check for Customization: Many wine clubs offer great flexibility in the selection of wine color, frequency of shipping, and payment methods. We use this bend-over-backwards information to help us rate wine clubs.

Read the Fine Print: We check all marketing copy, customer service information, FAQ pages, and return policies. When we find holes in the information, we contact the wine clubs to make sure we know what they will do for their customers and what they won’t.

About Our Wine Club Ratings System

We used to rate all wine of the month clubs based on how much value they provide. What we discovered is that many of the premium wine clubs aren’t about primarily about value (and we don’t think they need to be) and that our readers were missing opportunities to find those premium wine clubs. So... we created a new two-tiered ratings system!

Value wine clubs are rated on these criteria:

  • Quality-to-Price Ratio of the wines they’re offering
  • How the wines are selected. Are any consumers involved in the wine selection process?
  • Customization of wine color, billing frequency, and shipping frequency
  • Reorder discounts
  • Introductory offer
  • Shipping & handling costs
  • Are there any other extras?
  • Customer service policies

Premium wine clubs are rated on these criteria:

  • Is a professional sommelier or WSET-certified person involved in the wine selection process?
  • Are the wines limited production?
  • Are the wines undiscovered gems or hard-to-find?
  • Are the prices justified?
  • Are there allocations for reorders?

We invite your feedback on our wine club reviews and ratings systems both on individual wine clubs and as a whole.

© All wine club ratings & reviews shown on Wine Club Reviews are copyrighted.
We were featured on Beer Club Reviews

Perhaps a beer club is more your speed? Check out our beer clubs and gifts site, too!